Is Getting a New Engine Like Getting a New Car?

Is Getting a New Engine Like Getting a New Car?

Is Getting a New Engine Like Getting a New Car?

Perhaps when you entered the shop, you discovered that your engine had kicked it. Given the price estimate, you might be considering purchasing a brand-new vehicle instead. But is buying a new engine comparable to buying a new vehicle?

Unless the engine in your automobile is the only problem, obtaining a new engine is not the same as getting a new car. Any engine problems can be resolved with a new engine, but not their underlying causes. However, if your car is flawless other than the engine, it would be just as excellent as “new.”

A new engine effectively transforms an older vehicle into a brand-new one, according to engine experts and antique automobile enthusiasts. If there is a lot going on under the hood, a mechanic might advise you that a new engine is the least of your concerns. We’ll explain what this implies below.

Engine Replacement vs. Buying a New Car

A new engine is very expensive, as you may regretfully discover. A new car can cost a lot of money in a market that can be so hot or cool. So, is it better to get one because a new engine makes your automobile like new?

A new engine won’t make your automobile brand new, but it can make it run more like it did when it was. All of the components in new cars, including the brakes, interior, etc., are almost without flaw. A new engine could make your automobile run like new, but it doesn’t mean you should buy a brand-new vehicle.

Consider it in this manner. A new heating system wouldn’t convert a decent house into a brand-new one if you found one on the market that also needed a dozen new appliances and a new heating system.

Even while a new engine makes a car perform better, there are still a dozen other components that could use replacement. A car has many moving parts and is more than just its engine. Without even mentioning the transmission, suspension, and steering, you should at the very least think about the brakes, belts, battery, and interior.

Now, if you have a car that is in excellent shape, has had every item replaced, and you add an engine, then yes, it might be somewhat comparable to a new car. However, you’ll still need to take the vehicle’s mileage into account. An engine needs to be replaced every eight years on average. Additionally, mileage doesn’t always decrease to 0 when you buy a new car.

If you’ve ever had to decide between buying a new engine or a new car, you might not be interested in the exact meaning of the phrase “like new.” We list some of the benefits and drawbacks of replacing an engine as opposed to purchasing a new vehicle below.

A Greener Option Is to Buy a New Engine

Right, reduce, reuse, recycle.

You are only adding to the junk when you buy a new car and throw away the old, useless one. By purchasing a new engine and installing it in your new vehicle, you prevent one vehicle from being sent to a junkyard.

Each year, almost 27 million cars reach the end of their useful lives and the majority are scrapped after being disassembled. They are essentially used again after that. Over 25 million tons of recycled materials are recovered from end-of-life vehicles annually, and nearly 80% of their parts can be recycled or repurposed.

You should also think about how environmentally friendly your current vehicle is to determine whether getting rid of it will ultimately benefit the environment. You might be better off getting rid of your car if it produces a lot of pollution, has poor gas mileage, or isn’t environmentally friendly.

Changing the Engine May Not Be Enough to Fix All Your Problems

What gives the car its greatest functionality is difficult to discuss. Your car has a lot of functional components in addition to the engine. Even if your car’s engine was the issue, there might have been a deeper problem that a new engine can’t resolve.

Yes, a complete replacement would work if your engine has failed entirely. However, if another component in your car was to blame for the engine failure, your replacement engine is just a ticking time bomb.

You must identify the precise cause of your engine issue and replace any other broken components inside the engine. You cannot anticipate the new engine to survive as long as the old one if this is the case.

Even if the root cause of the engine issues is resolved, you will still need to address other issues as they arise. It’s crucial to perform preventative maintenance since it will end up saving you a ton of money. To find out when your automobile requires new brakes, tires, belts, etc., see your owner’s manual.

A New Engine’s Cost Compared to The Cost of A New Car

Overall, the cost of the new engine should be less than that of a new vehicle. However, it will also shield you from the extra costs we rarely consider when purchasing a car. When buying a new car, you must take license, registration, and taxes into account. Additionally, when you purchase a new car, insurance costs typically increase.

That stated, the expense to replace an automobile engine might range from $4,000 to $7,000. It will still be expensive, but not as expensive as buying a new automobile. In addition to the costs we previously covered, you might want to consider the cost of a down payment and a new monthly payment if you’re only concerned with your immediate financial situation.

It’s also crucial to consider your automobile’s present value because installing a $7,000 engine in a $3,000 car that may later develop other problems could be a low-reward decision.

A Professional Should Install a New Engine

Perhaps you’ve been handling more and more car-related issues on your own. Learning how to replace your wipers and change your oil can save you a lot of money. You might attempt to replace an engine yourself, as this video explains:

Engines are heavy, and removing one from your car might be dangerous if you’ve never done it before. Furthermore, if you’ve never changed an engine, you run the chance of breaking other components and increasing your bill. But you should really consider hiring a pro to do it. In the long run, DIY projects will probably cost you more money than hiring a pro would have.

Should I Buy a New Car or Replace My Engine?

When it comes down to it, the solution will be tailored to your budget and your car.

If your car is still relatively new and you are confident that this repair will keep it running well in the future, you should replace the engine. However, if your car is in poor shape, you might consider getting a new one. And if you’re strapped for funds, think about getting the engine fixed instead.

Once more, it will depend on your circumstances and the type of vehicle you drive. Driving a forty-year-old car that is going to die and has thousands in savings is very different from driving a brand-new car that had some poor luck with the engine and is strapped for cash. There is much to think about.

You can use the following video to see how a person and an expert make decisions:

If you viewed the clip, you would see that they talked about the car’s value, the family’s debt condition, the problems with the present engine, and the amount of savings the family had.

Along with the price of your new engine, you also need to take into account the age of the car. You might be able to get a better rate on the replacement engine if you have a connection with a mechanic and only pay for parts and not labor.

The market pricing for the car is something else worth discussing, particularly at this time. During the epidemic, car prices rose by 40%, and they are just now beginning to decline. The pandemic significantly raised prices for both new and used cars, with price increases only occurring in 2022.


Even though you might think the engine is the only thing keeping your automobile running, acquiring a new engine isn’t necessarily the same as obtaining a new car. Getting a new engine will improve how well your car runs, especially if the old engine is damaged, but it won’t make any other problems go away. When choosing between a new engine and a brand-new vehicle, consider all of your alternatives carefully.